Breastfeeding or bottle feeding? Deciding what's best for you and your baby

Deciding whether to breast or bottle feed? These pros and cons could help you.

The decision to breastfeed or bottle feed your baby is completely unique to you, and should be based on however you feel most comfortable.

It's generally recognised that breast milk is better for a newborn baby due to the nutritious value and strength building benefits that support your baby's immune system in a way that formula milk can't, and The Department of Health advise mums to breastfeed for at least the first six months of your baby's life.

However, many mums aren't physically able to breastfeed, whilst for others breastfeeding isn't an option for reasons beyond their control.

If you are deciding whether to breastfeed or bottle feed, there are lots of factors to weigh up. But, when deciding what's best for you and your baby, consider the pros and cons and be sure to talk through your plans and get advice from your health visitor as well.


Pros of breastfeeding

  • Your breast milk contains the perfect amount of nutrition and hydration to build your baby's immune system which contributes towards fending off illness and making them as strong as possible

  • Breast milk is free! Considering how expensive baby's are, this is a huge win in the finance department as they drink A LOT of milk

  • Breast milk is readily available whenever your baby needs it, which means no carrying bottles or sterilising equipment around with you

  • It's a chance to bond with your baby and get to know them, spending special quality time with them

Cons of breastfeeding

  • It can make some mothers uncomfortable and they dislike doing it, especially in public

  • Your breasts can become engorged, swollen and generally painful - which is never fun!

  • Your nipples are set to get a lot more attention than normal and can begin to crack or bleed which can be quite painful

Bottle feeding

Pros of bottle feeding

  • If your breasts are in pain or you have developed mastitis, bottle feeding will be a welcome relief. It's more important to be a happy, healthy mum than to force yourself to do something you find painful

  • You can share feeding duties - yay! No longer is the pressure all on you, your partner or family are just as capable of feeding your baby, which means you can get some rest!

  • You can measure exactly how much milk your baby is drinking every day. If they're draining each bottle and still crying for more it could mean they're going through a growth spurt or if they don't drink their usual amount they may be feeling poorly

  • You can now buy ready-made formula milk, microwave sterilisers and a huge number of anti-colic teats and bottles all designed to make bottle feeding a quicker, easier and happier experience for both of you

Cons of bottle feeding

  • Unfortunately the truth is formula just doesn't have the same nutritional benefits as breast milk for your baby, your breast milk is designed especially to give your little one the best start in life

  • Formula is expensive and with so much to buy for your baby already it feels like a shame to not use the free resources that you have

  • A lot of preparation goes into making up a bottle for your baby. It can cause an added strain on your already newly hectic lifestyle because of the hassle it takes to organise the equipment, sterilise, prepare and carry around the bottles

  • Did you breastfeed or bottle feed? What sort of experience did you have? Let us know in the comments below!

Trusted, informative, and empathetic – GoodTo is the ultimate online destination for mums. Established in 2007, our 15-year-strong archive of content includes more than 18,000 articles, 1,500 how-to videos, and 7,000 recipes.